Whiskies by points

By name

By meeting

Points awarded

WHISKIES
Over the years, hundreds of different single malt whiskies have been sampled at members meetings. Because not all information, especially age and ABV, was recorded at meetings, the same whisky might be stored as two (or more) different whiskies. Non of the lists of whiskies sampled are complete because the minutes between March 2009 and March 2017 are not available.

The following scoring system was proposed and adopted at meeting 11 (Friday 27 August 1999):

0-70:	Poor whisky with missing aroma and taste
71-75:	A simple whisky without concentration of aroma and taste
76-80:	A simple, but well made whisky, thought without depth, concentration and personality
81-85:	A well made whisky with personality and quality above average
86-90:	A good whisky with marked personality and quality
91-95:	A whisky of world class
96-100:	An outstanding whisky

- Red font on yellow background indicates 'Whiskies of the Night'
- Asterices (*) indicate that not all members present at the meeting gave the whisky points
- Click the points (left column) to display the meeting details

Points	Whisky	Age	ABV	Region	Type
*95.5	Laphroaig	10 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
95.5	Springbank	32 YO	54.4%	Campeltown	Single malt
94.4	Laphroaig	10 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
*94.3	Caol Ila			Islay	Single malt
*93	Laphroaig		48.0%	Islay	Single malt
93	Bowmore			Islay	Single malt
92.3	Laphroaig	10 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
*91.8	Dailuaine	22 YO		Speyside
91.5	Bowmore			Islay	Single malt
91.3	Glenfarclas 105		60.0%	Highland	Single malt
91.1	Bowmore			Islay	Single malt
*91.1	Glenrothes	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
91	Breath of Islay	13 YO	53.4%	Islay	Single malt
90.5	Laphroaig	10 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
*90.5	Glen Morven	12 YO	43.0%	Islay	Pure malt
*90.5	Glenrothes	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*90.2	Port Ellen	28 YO	53.8%	Islay	Single malt
90.1	Ardbeg Limited 1975 Edition		43.0%	Islay	Single malt
90.1	The Balvenie	15 YO	50.7%	Speyside	Single malt
90	Ardbeg	17 YO		Islay	Single malt
89.9	Longrow	10 YO	57.0%	Campeltown
89.9	Caol Ila 1982	25 YO	46.0%	Islay	Single malt
89.7	Caol Ila 1994	10 YO	43.0%	Islay	Single malt
89.7	The Glenlivet Archive	15 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
89.7	Gordon & MacPhail Cask 1987	12 YO	58.0%	Lowland	Single malt
89.7	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
89.4	Bowmore		56.0%	Islay	Single malt
89.3	Talisker	18 YO		Highland	Single malt
88.9	Bowmore Darkest			Islay	Single malt
*88.8	Balvenie Doublewood	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
88.7	Bowmore		56.0%	Islay	Single malt
*88.7	SMWS 3.59	10 YO	56.6%		Single malt
88.7	Signatory Vintage 1980	21 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*88.6	Provenance Caol Ila	6 YO	46.0%	Islay	Single malt
88.6	Ardbeg	10 YO		Islay	Single malt
88.5	Springbank	10 YO		Campeltown
*88	Highland Park Viking Honour	12 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
88	Ailsa Bay		49.8%	Lowland	Single malt
*88	Isle of Jura			Island
88	Mortlach	16 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*88	Jack Daniel's			America	Bourbon
*88	Lagavulin	16 YO	43.0%	Islay	Single malt
88	Highland Park	13 YO	43.0%	Island	Single malt
88	Dalwhinnie		43.0%	Highland	Single malt
*88	Bowmore	12 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
*88	Talisker	10 YO	45.8%	Highland	Single malt
87.5	Laphroaig Quarter Cask			Islay	Single malt
*87.4	Royal Lochnagar	24 YO	55.7%	Highland
*87.3	Ardbeg	10 YO		Islay	Single malt
87	Littlemill	10 YO		Lowland	Single malt
*86.9	NSMWS Cask 0336	10 YO	xx.x%	Islay	Single malt
86.9	SMWS 19.38	19 YO	52.9%	Highland	Single malt
*86.8	Talisker	10 YO		Highland	Single malt
*86.8	The Glenlivet Archive	21 YO		Speyside	Single malt
*86.8	Balvenie	10 YO		Speyside
*86.8	Caol Ila	12 YO	43.0%	Islay	Single malt
86.8	Talisker	10 YO	45.8%	Highland	Single malt
86.6	Mackillop's Choice Dufftown 1982	25 YO		Speyside	Single malt
86.6	Scapa	14 YO		Island	Single malt
*86.6	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
86.6	Longmorn	15 YO	45.0%
86.6	Bruichladdich	10 YO	43.0%	Islay	Single malt
*86.6	The Corriemohr		40.0%		Pure malt
86.3	Glen Moray			Speyside
86.3	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
*86.3	Fettecairn			Highland
*86.3	Glenmorangie		43.0%	Highland	Single malt
86.3	Glenkinchie	10 YO		Lowland
86	Oban	14 YO		Highland	Single malt
*86	Ledaig	15 YO	43.0%	Island	Single malt
*85.9	Bowmore			Islay	Single malt
85.8	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
85.5	Bowmore	12 YO		Islay	Single malt
*85.5	Glenmorangie	10 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
85.5	Royal Lochnagar	12 YO		Highland
85.5	Glenfiddich Solera Reserve	15 YO		Speyside
85.5	Glenkeith	10 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*85.2	Ben Nevis	10 YO		Highland	Single malt
85.2	Tamnavulin	12 YO		Speyside	Single malt
85	Linkwood 'Dun Bhegan'	10 YO		Speyside	Single malt
*84.9	Bruichladdich	12 YO		Islay	Single malt
84.9	Caol Ila	22 YO	55.7%	Islay	Single malt
*84.8	Glenkinchie	10 YO	43.0%	Lowland	Single malt
84.7	Bowmore	15 YO	43.0%	Islay	Single malt
84.7	Craigellachie	14 YO		Speyside
*84.7	Ardbeg	10 YO		Islay	Single malt
84.7	The Macallan	18 YO		Highland	Single malt
84.7	Bruichladdich			Islay	Single malt
84.5	Speymalt		40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
84.4	Ardbeg	10 YO		Islay	Single malt
84.4	Glendronach	15 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
84.4	Glen Garioch			Highland
*84.3	Glengoyne	10 YO		Highland
*84.3	Balvenie Doublewood	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
84.3	SMWS 10.48			Islay	Single malt
*84.3	Glenmorangie	10 YO	57.2%	Highland	Single malt
*84.3	Cardhu	12 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
84.2	Ileach		40.0%	Islay
84.1	Bowmore Darkest	15 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
84.1	Tomintoul	16 YO		Speyside
84.1	Eilan Gillan	13 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
84.1	Caol Ila	22 YO	55.7%	Islay	Single malt
84	Glenmorangie	13 YO	43.0%	Highland	Single malt
83.9	Smokehead		43.0%	Islay	Single malt
83.8	AnCnoc	12 YO		Highland	Single malt
83.8	Glen Moray	8 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*83.7	The Glenlivet	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside
83.6	House of Lords	10 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
83.6	SMWS 122.11	13 YO	57.8%	Highland	Single malt
83.6	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
*83.6	Dailuaine	22 YO	xx.x%	Speyside
*83.6	Dalwhinnie		43.0%	Highland	Single malt
83.5	Glenmorangie	10 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
83.5	The Famous Grouse	12 YO			Single malt
*83	Chieftains	13 YO	48.0%	Highland	Single malt
83	Aberfeldy	12 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
*83	Highland Park Svein		40.0%	Island	Single malt
83	Miltonduff	10 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
83	Cardhu	12 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
*83	Balvenie Doublewood	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*83	Highland Park	16 YO	40.0%	Island	Single malt
83	Bennachie	21 YO
*83	Glenmorangie	13 YO	43.0%	Highland	Single malt
83	Dalwhinnie	15 YO		Highland
*83	The Arran			Island	Single malt
83	BenRiach	10 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
83	Old Fettercairn	10 YO		Highland	Single malt
83	Highland Park	18 YO		Island	Single malt
*83	Glenlossie	10 YO	43.0%	Speyside
83	Craigellachie	14 YO	43.0%	Speyside
83	The Singleton	17 YO		Speyside	Single malt
83	Glenmorangie		43.0%	Highland	Single malt
83	Glendronach	15 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
83	Old Pulteney	12 YO		Highland	Single malt
83	Glen Ord	10 YO		Highland
82.5	The Benriach		48.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*82.5	Highland Park	16 YO	40.0%	Island	Single malt
82.4	Ardmore Legacy		40.0%	Highland	Single malt
*82.4	Highland Park Harald		40.0%	Island	Single malt
82.4	The Singleton	12 YO		Speyside
82.4	Glen Parker			Speyside	Single malt
*82.3	Royal Lochnagar	12 YO		Highland
82.2	Balvenie	10 YO		Speyside
*82.2	Auchentoshan	10 YO		Lowland	Single malt
82.1	Cu Dhub			Speyside	Single malt
*81.8	The Dalmore		43.0%		Single malt
81.8	Aberlour	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside
*81.8	The Glenlivet	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside
81.8	Glendronach	12 YO		Speyside
81.8	Bowmore			Islay	Single malt
*81.8	Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve	18 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
81.6	Glenrothes			Speyside
81.6	Glencadam	15 YO		Highland
81.6	Glenfarclas	12 YO	xx.x%	Speyside	Single malt
81.3	Chieftains	13 YO	48.0%	Highland	Single malt
*81.3	The Glenlivet Nadurra	16 YO		Speyside	Single malt
81.3	Glengoyne	10 YO		Highland
81.1	Benromach			Speyside	Single malt
81.1	Tormore	12 YO		Speyside	Single malt
81.1	SMWS 53.85	11 YO	xx.x%	Islay	Single malt
81	Isle of Jura			Island
*81	Glen Ranoch		40.0%	Highland	Single malt
81	Johnny Walker	15 YO			Pure malt
81	Glen Deveron	12 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
80.9	Glen Garioch			Highland
*80.8	Glenfiddich Solera Reserve	15 YO		Speyside
*80.5	Glenmorangie	10 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
80.5	SMWS 93.15	13 YO	xx.x%	Campeltown	Single malt
*80.5	Glenmorangie			Highland	Single malt
*80.5	Stronachie
80.5	Old Pulteney	12 YO		Highland	Single malt
*80.5	Tomatin	10 YO	40.0%	Highland
80.3	Connemara			Ireland	Single malt
*80.2	Balvenie	10 YO		Speyside
80.1	Tomintoul	10 YO		Speyside	Single malt
*80.1	Aberfeldy	15 YO	43.0%	Highland	Single malt
*80	Speyburn			Highland	Single malt
79.9	Glenkinchie	10 YO	43.0%	Lowland	Single malt
*79.7	Tormore	12 YO		Speyside	Single malt
*79.7	Glenfiddich Caoran Reserve	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*79.7	Chivas Regal	21 YO			Blended
79.5	Three Chimneys
79.4	AnCnoc	12 YO		Highland	Single malt
79.4	Auchentoshan	10 YO		Lowland	Single malt
*79.4	Glen Ranoch		40.0%	Highland	Single malt
79.3	Strathisla	12 YO	43.0%	Highland	Single malt
79.3	The Arran			Island	Single malt
79.3	Mortlach	13 YO		Speyside	Single malt
79.2	Glenmorangie	10 YO	40.0%	Highland	Single malt
*79.1	Macleod's	10 YO	40.0%	Islay	Single malt
78.8	Glen Moray	8 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*78.8	Ledaig		42.0%	Island	Single malt
*78.8	Chivas Regal	12 YO	40.0%
78.8	The Glenlivet	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside
78.7	Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve	18 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*78.7	Balblair	12 YO	43.0%	Highland	Single malt
78.6	Bruichladdich	10 YO		Islay	Single malt
78.2	Aberfeldy			Highland	Single malt
*78	Glenfiddich	12 YO	40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
78	Kornog	3 YO	46.0%	France	Single malt
*78	Scottish Pride	12 YO	40.0%		Pure malt
78	Old Pulteney	12 YO		Highland	Single malt
78	Loch Lomond			Highland	Single malt
78	Auchentoshan	10 YO		Lowland	Single malt
*78	Black Bush		43.0%		Blended
78	Drumguish	10 YO		Highland	Single malt
78	Glenfarclas	10 YO		Speyside	Single malt
78	Glenfiddich	12 YO	43.0%	Speyside
*77.6	Glenburgie	10 YO		Speyside
*77.4	Drumguish	10 YO		Highland	Single malt
77.4	Miltonduff Glenlivet		43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
*77.3	Tariquet Armagnac		45.0%	France	Armangnac
77.2	Ledaig		42.0%	Island	Single malt
*77.2	Glen Ranoch		40.0%	Highland	Single malt
*77.2	Black Barrel		43.0%		Single grain
77	BenRiach	10 YO	43.0%	Speyside	Single malt
76.6	Glen Moray			Speyside
76.6	Jura Legacy	10 YO		Island	Single malt
*76.1	Glen Scanlan		40.0%		Pure malt
76	Cragganmore			Speyside
*76	Chivas Regal	10 YO			Blended
76	The Edradour	10 YO	43.0%	Highland
*75.9	The Famous Grouse				Blended
*75.9	Arran	7 YO		Island	Single malt
75.9	Knockando			Speyside
*75.8	Tormore	12 YO		Speyside	Single malt
*75.5	Royal Swan	10 YO			Pure malt
75.5	Glen Grant		40.0%	Speyside	Single malt
75.2	Scottish Pride	12 YO	40.0%		Pure malt
75.2	Black Barrel		43.0%		Single grain
*75.1	Bushmills Single Malt	10 YO	40.0%	Ireland	Single malt
*74.3	The Fat Trout			Speyside	Single malt
*74.3	SMWS 13.27	9 YO	59.8%	Highland	Single malt
73.8	Chivas Regal	12 YO			Blended
*73.8	Ballentine				Blended
73.6	Tomatin	10 YO	40.0%	Highland
*73	Paddy			Ireland	Blended
*73	Paddy			Ireland	Blended
*73	The Tyrconnell			Ireland	Single malt
73	Paddy			Ireland	Blended
73	Tullibardine	7 YO		Highland
71.7	Bushmills Single Malt	10 YO	40.0%	Ireland	Single malt
65.3	Auchentoshan	10 YO		Lowland	Single malt
46.4	Loch Dhu	10 YO	40.0%

Asterices (*) indicate that not all attendees gave the whisky a score